Chicago Public Schools closings do not lead to achievement boosts for displaced students

Steve Koppes
Associate News DirectorUniversity Communications

A report released today by the Consortium on Chicago School Research shows that eight in 10 Chicago Public Schools students displaced by school closings transferred to schools that rank in the bottom half of the CPS system on standardized tests. However, because most displaced students transferred from one low-performing school to another, the move did not, on average, significantly affect student achievement.

The report, prepared by CCSR researchers Julia Gwynne and Marisa de la Torre, demonstrates that the success of a school closing policy hinges on the quality of the receiving schools that accept the displaced students. The report "When Schools Close: Effect on Displaced Students in Chicago Public Schools," showed that one year after school closings, displaced students who re-enrolled in the weakest receiving schools (those with test scores in the bottom quartile of all system schools) experienced an achievement loss of more than a month in reading and half-a-month in math. Meanwhile, students who re-enrolled in the strongest receiving schools (those in the top quartile) experienced an achievement gain of nearly one month in reading and more than two months in math.

The authors focused on 18 CPS elementary schools that were closed between 2001 and 2006 because of chronically poor academic performance or enrollment significantly below capacity. The schools enrolled 5,445 students at the time of their closings. To assess the academic effects of closing on these students, the study compares students ages 8 and older displaced by school closings with students in similar schools that did not close. The comparison group provides an estimate of how the displaced students should have performed on a range of outcomes had their schools not been closed.

The study reflects CCSR's commitment to studying education issues that are top priorities in Chicago and districts nationwide. In Chicago, multiple rounds of school closings have prompted a powerful backlash from some teachers, students, community members and advocacy groups. Nevertheless, CPS and many other large urban school systems continue to make school closings a cornerstone of reform, touting the financial and academic benefits of closing under-utilized or underperforming campuses.

CCSR is part of the University's Urban Education Initiative, which also includes a teacher-training program and charter schools.